After much anticipation, Apple has finally lifted the curtain on its new credit card — well, sort of.
Apple AAPL, +0.90% officially unveiled the credit card during a Monday press event alongside other new services, including the company’s new gaming and video subscription offerings. The card is being offered in partnership with Goldman Sachs GS, -0.35% marking the bank’s first credit card offering, and card network Mastercard MA, -0.33%
“What the iPod was to the music industry, and what the iPhone was for cell phones and mobile carriers, so is the Apple Card to financial services.” — Richard Crone, payments industry consultant
What we already know
In hyping the new card, dubbed simply Apple Card, the tech giant played up a number of features. Cardholders will earn 3% cash back on any Apple-related purchases, 2% back on anything bought with Apple Pay and 1% back on all transactions performed with the physical titanium card.
Cash-back rewards will accrue daily in the Apple Cash app — that money can be used to make purchases or for person-to-person payments with the app. Apple has also integrated new features into the Wallet app so that card holders can better track their spending and adjust card payments to fit their financial needs.
These and other features may seem flashy — but they’ve already attracted some skeptics. For starters, many other credit cards come with better rewards, including the U.S. Bank USB, -0.78% “Altitude Reserve Visa Infinite” card, which pays back 3% on all transactions completed via mobile pay.
(Apple did not return a request for comment, and Goldman Sachs declined to comment for this story.)
Don’t miss: Investing app Stash launches debit rewards in an effort to attract more banking customers
Nevertheless, the card still seems poised to attract the attention of Apple devotees — those people who have the latest Macbook, iPhone and Apple Watch and are members of the device upgrade program.
But once you get past the splashy features, there’s a lot Apple isn’t telling consumers about its new credit card.
Here’s what you should watch out for:
Apple wants you to use mobile payments
OK, maybe this isn’t really a secret Apple is hiding — after all, why else would the card offer better rewards for purchases made through Apple Pay? Nevertheless, those planning to sign up for the Apple card should understand the company’s reasoning for offering it in the first place.
Currently, Apple is fighting something of a losing battle when it comes to dominance in the mobile pay space. Apple Pay has only 32 million users, according to research from Richard Crone, a consultant in the payments industry. That’s only slightly more than the number of people who use Walmart Pay (31 million) WMT, -1.13% and the Starbucks app (25 million) SBUX, -0.30% And it’s far fewer than the number of people who use PayPal and its person-to-person payments subsidiary Venmo (267 million) PYPL, -0.08%
And payments experts have expressed skepticism that Americans will adopt mobile pay with the same fervor as their peers in other countries, especially China. “Mobile payments have grown glacially because in a lot of ways people don’t see a compelling reason to use them instead of just breaking out the old plastic card,” said Matt Schulz, industry analyst with personal-finance website CompareCards.
Others have argued that the Apple card could be a watershed moment, thanks in part to the financial management services Apple is adding to the Wallet app. “It is empowering financial services at the most basic level,” Crone said. “What the iPod was to the music industry, and what the iPhone was for cell phones and mobile carriers, so is the Apple Card to financial services.”
Goldman Sachs isn’t selling your data, but...
Privacy was one of the major selling points in Apple’s presentation Monday. The titanium Apple Card notably won’t include a card number — a choice aimed at curbing would-be criminals looking to steal credit card numbers to make unauthorized purchases. Additionally, Apple said that Goldman Sachs has agreed never to sell cardholders’ data to third parties.
What Apple didn’t say is that Goldman Sachs is keeping that data for its own uses. Ahead of Monday’s announcement, some had predicted that Apple and Goldman Sachs would use the data they collect to make personalized loan offers to card holders.
That prediction, Crone said, has essentially come to fruition, because the financial management features basically allow people to customize their balance repayment terms. Apple and Goldman theoretically may go a step further in the future to offer installment loans to card holders for big purchases at the point of sale, using the information they’ve collected and analyzed about consumers’ spending habits.
Mobile payments have grown glacially because in a lot of ways people don’t see a compelling reason to use them instead of just breaking out the old plastic card. Matt Schulz, industry analyst with personal-finance website CompareCards
You might experience some kinks with customer service
While this isn’t the first time Apple has offered a co-branded card, it is Goldman Sachs’ first credit card. And as the bank supporting the card, consumers could be in for a bumpy ride when it comes to customer service so long as this is still relatively new ground for Goldman.
“This product has the potential to attract a lot of consumers really fast, but I don’t know that they’ll be capable to deal with the customer-service demand,” said Odysseas Papadimitriou, CEO of personal-finance website WalletHub.
In particular, Goldman and Apple will lack institutional knowledge when it comes to processing claims related to fraudulent charges.
Read more: The phone number that secures your Facebook account isn’t as safe as you think
The interest rate may not end up being that low
Apple describes it as “the first credit card that actually encourages you to pay less interest.” And the website says the company’s goal is “to provide interest rates that are among the lowest in the industry.”
But when you read the fine print, it states that the variable annual percentage rates (APR) will range from 13.24% to 24.24% as of March 2019, based on creditworthiness.
The national average APR is currently 17.67%, according to CreditCards.com. In other words, consumers with stellar credit would get below average interest rates. Consumers with poor credit could easily find themselves stuck with a rather high interest rate.
And while the card ostensibly doesn’t charge any fees, including late fees or foreign transaction fees, Apple reserves the right to up the interest rate on the card if consumers aren’t paying off their balances.
Moreover, Apple has not specified whether it will set limits based on creditworthiness for who can even receive a card. “People need to understand what their credit score is,” Schulz said. “The last thing anyone wants is to apply for a card thinking they’ll get a 12% rate and then get a 25% rate.”
The rewards program could cause you to spend more money
Research has shown that mobile pay may cause people to spend more money to begin with. And when you layer rewards on top of that, it could quickly become a budget breaker.
Apple’s promise of rewards accruing daily is somewhat unusual for the credit-card industry. And people hunting for savings might be led astray if they become too obsessed with what they’re getting in cash back.
“It’s important that people don’t get caught up seeing that cash-back come in every day,” Schulz said. “It could be good for people who pay their balance in full, but the last thing anyone should do is overspend to get rewards.”
Speaking of over-spending, while Apple claims it won’t limit rewards, that’s not entirely true. The Apple Cash card will still come with a credit limit — meaning that people won’t be able to spend with abandon in search of cashback without making some credit card payments.
Consumers will not benefit from a level playing field anymore. Odysseas Papadimitriou, CEO of WalletHub
Apple wants to become a card network like Visa or MasterCard
The hype surrounding Apple Card may belie the tech company’s true intentions. As Papadimitriou argues, Apple may not be looking to best its rivals like Google GOOGL, -0.99% and Samsung SSNLF, -3.07% in the smartphone space or PayPal in the mobile pay space.
Instead, it could be looking to replace Visa V, -0.70% and Mastercard. “Why have the middle man?” Papadimitriou said. Through this credit card, Apple could learn what it takes to manage a card network. If its goal of boosting mobile payment comes to fruition, Apple Pay could replace Visa or Mastercard when it comes to managing card transactions.
Naturally, companies like Google, Samsung and Microsoft MSFT, -0.97% would wade into this pool were Apple to follow this path.
However, this could reduce competition: Companies like Visa and Mastercard jockey when it comes to the fees they charge merchants for credit-card transactions. If the number of card networks were to shrink thanks to Apple’s ambitions, the networks would have more leverage to charge higher fees. Those fees could then be passed on to consumers in the form of higher prices.
In the near-term, Apple Card is already poised to work out better for Apple Pay users than most of their other credit cards. As Papadimitriou explains, there’s nothing to stop Apple from stacking the deck in its favor. “Consumers will not benefit from a level playing field anymore,” he said.