Aly Song | Reuters
A facebook display during the China International Import Expo (CIIE), at the National Exhibition and Convention Center in Shanghai, China, November 5, 2018.
One faction on Wall Street sees major upside for Facebook if its secretive cryptocurrency plan works out.
The social network is reportedly developing a cryptocurrency that could be part of a multi-billion-dollar revenue opportunity, Barclays internet analyst Ross Sandler said in a note to clients Monday.
Sandler forecasted as much as $19 billion in additional revenue by 2021 from "Facebook Coin," in his upside case. Conservatively, the firm sees a base-case of an incremental $3 billion in revenue from a successful cryptocurrency implementation.
"Merely establishing this revenue stream starts to change the story for Facebook shares in our view," Sandler said.
Facebook is reportedly developing a cryptocurrency for global payments that will be tied to the value of traditional currencies, and available to use through its messenger "WhatsApp," according to Bloomberg and The New York Times. Facebook has not publicly commented on its plans.
Price volatility has been one major roadblock to bitcoin's widespread adoption as an everyday payment option. But Facebook's digital currency, a so-called "stable coin," would likely be less attractive to speculators because of its fixed price tied to a currency like the U.S. dollar.
Facebook's current business model came under fire from consumers, politicians and advertisers last year. Its share price tanked after a series of snafus. For one, British political consulting firm Cambridge Analytica collected data on more than 50 million Facebook users without permission. Still, Facebook earnings have continued to increase, and the share price has rallied roughly 30 percent this year.
Expanding into payments could give Facebook a lifeline if investors suddenly become less forgiving. Using some form of cryptocurrency could generate a new revenue option — something "sorely needed at this stage of the company's narrative," Sandler said.
"Any attempt to build out revenue streams outside of advertising, especially those that don't abuse user privacy are likely to be well-received by Facebook's shareholders, Sandler said.
Barclays based its Facebook revenue estimates off of Google's digital distribution service, which is also the official app store for Android's operating system. "Google Play," as it's called, generates $6 in "net" revenue per user now. Facebook could see a "similar cadence," across its nearly 3 billion users in 2021.
Facebook having its own virtual currency would allow for more premium content to find its way back to Facebook, Sandler said, as companies re-establish themselves on the social network as a strategic partner
Paying through Facebook
Sandler pointed to Facebook's original payment ambitions almost a decade ago. The Menlo Park, California-based company created a virtual currency in 2010 called "Facebook credits," similar to modern-day cryptocurrency. Users would pre-pay for these virtual coins using domestic currencies, and then use those credits for in-app-purchases. The company required a user to pay using a debit or credit card upfront, and each virtual credit cost about 10 cents.
The major problem, according to Sandler, was that Facebook had to bear the interchange cost, "which negatively impacts the profitability of the business, especially when making high volumes of lower-value transactions."
Since then, Facebook and the cryptocurrency sector have matured. The company has a much larger user base, and more mega-apps like Instagram and WhatsApp to which it can distribute content. The company's new cryptocurrency plan could potentially "re-invigorate that business strategy," Sandler said.
"Based on our checks, the first version of Facebook Coin may be a single purpose coin for micro-payments and domestic p2p money transfer (in-country), very similar to the original credits from 2010 and Venmo today," Sandler said.
Stephen Lam | Reuters
David Marcus, vice president of Messaging Products at Facebook, speaks on stage during the annual Facebook F8 developers conference in San Jose, California, April 18, 2017.
The scope of this project, according to Sandler, is larger than those previous ambitions. He pointed to the well-known leader of Facebook's blockchain and cryptocurrency efforts — former PayPal president David Marcus. Facebook has been steadily building out its blockchain team, recently hiring a group of employees from start-up Chainspace.
There are still challenges though. Facebook needs to demonstrate a value proposition for users "above what is available today in payments" and build trust after its laundry list of issues in 2018, Sandler said. Global payments systems also tend to bring more regulatory scrutiny.
But if the stable-coin is successful, Sandler said he sees no reason why Facebook couldn't get into consumer lending, remittance and physical payments "eventually."
